STRUCTURED LITERACY – ONE SIZE FITS ALL ?

Back to DYSLEXIA

Is Structured Literacy a One-Size-Fits-All Approach?


One of the most common misunderstandings is that Structured Literacy is a “one-size-fits-all” approach. It is not. People hear the word “structured” and immediately assume it means rigid teaching, prescribed lessons and no flexibility. The same misunderstanding often applies to explicit teaching, with some assuming it means teachers must follow a script and cannot differentiate, be creative or make learning enjoyable.

But neither structure nor explicit teaching means rigidity. Teachers can still use games, discussion, engaging activities and different ways for children to practise and apply what they have learned. What matters is that instruction is carefully planned, clearly modelled and responsive to the learner.

This is where the misunderstanding lies: consistent teaching does not mean rigid delivery.

Structured Literacy is a framework for teaching literacy, not a single programme or a prescribed set of lessons. Its evidence-based principles apply to teaching literacy to all children who can learn, including neurodivergent learners and those with additional learning needs.

Our brains may develop and function differently, but the fundamental cognitive processes involved in learning are broadly the same. What differs is the individual child. Children bring different strengths, prior knowledge and learning needs, including differences in working memory, processing speed and language abilities. These influence how quickly they acquire and retain knowledge, how much practice they need and the level of support required.

The science informs how we teach and how we adapt that teaching to the individual learner.


Understanding the Structured Literacy Framework

As the DEB Structured Literacy Framework illustrates, Structured Literacy brings together the Science of Reading, the Science of Learning and the Science of Instruction. These three areas provide the research foundation for understanding what children need to learn, how children learn and how to teach that knowledge effectively.

The framework also identifies who delivers instruction across the three tiers of a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS), and what needs to be taught. This includes the interconnected components of literacy: phonemic awareness, phonics, spelling, morphology, syllable and stress patterns, orthographic conventions, vocabulary, background knowledge, sentence structure, grammar, text structure, handwriting, fluency, comprehension, written expression and critical thinking, with oral language integrated throughout reading and writing development.

It also outlines how this knowledge is taught, through explicit, systematic, cumulative and responsive instruction, guided by assessment, targeted feedback, scaffolding and mastery of learning. This ensures teaching is carefully planned while remaining responsive to individual learners.


A Structured Literacy approach is not the same as a programme

This distinction is important and often gets lost in discussions about Structured Literacy.

A Structured Literacy approach is grounded in the Science of Reading, the Science of Learning, and the Science of Instruction, and in the extensive body of research within each area. Training in the approach goes far beyond learning how to deliver lessons. It develops an understanding of how children learn to read and write, how learning happens, why certain instructional methods work, and how these areas of research work together to inform teaching.

This deeper knowledge helps teachers understand not just what to teach and how to teach it, but why they teach it that way. They can then draw on the research alongside their professional experience, classroom observations, and knowledge of individual learners to make informed decisions, adapt instruction, and respond when children struggle.

A Structured Literacy programme is a set of organised teaching materials and lessons designed to support literacy instruction. It may include decodable books, scripted lessons, activities, assessments and a planned scope and sequence.

Programmes absolutely have a place, and many provide valuable support for teachers and parents. However, we must not confuse the Structured Literacy Framework and approach that I advocate for, and that the Ministry of Education has outlined, with individual Structured Literacy programmes.

We need to think of programmes and resources as the scaffolds and tools that help teachers put the framework and approach into practice, rather than treating the programme as the approach itself.


Why training in the approach matters

Training to use a Structured Literacy programme is not the same as training in a Structured Literacy approach.

Many Structured Literacy programmes are designed primarily for mainstream classroom instruction, providing teachers with a planned scope and sequence, lessons and resources. However, not all children learn at the same pace, and some will require more teaching, additional practice or a different level of support.

This is why teachers need knowledge of the approach itself, not just how to deliver a particular programme. They need to understand the knowledge and skills that come before and after what they are teaching, recognise when a child has not mastered something, and know how to respond.

Training in the approach lets teachers draw on research alongside their professional experience and knowledge of the children in their classroom. It gives them the confidence and knowledge to exercise informed teacher judgement, including adapting the programme or resources they are using.

This is particularly important for children with dyslexia and other neurodivergent learners, who may require more intensive, individualised instruction and specialist intervention.

A programme provides teaching materials and a planned pathway. Training in the approach provides the deeper knowledge of why, what and how we teach.

The programme should support the teacher’s professional judgement, not replace it.


No single programme covers the full breadth of literacy

We also need to recognise that no single Structured Literacy programme covers every element of the comprehensive Structured Literacy Framework I have outlined.

Literacy instruction does not stop at phonics, decoding, spelling or sentence writing. Writing develops into paragraphs, extended compositions, essays and different forms of written expression. Reading extends into increasingly complex texts, comprehension, novel studies, read-alouds, discussion, analysis and critical thinking.

Oral language, vocabulary and background knowledge continue to develop throughout all these experiences.

Much of this learning also happens across the wider curriculum. Science, social sciences, history and other subjects build the knowledge, vocabulary, concepts and language that children draw on when reading, writing and making sense of increasingly complex information.

A decodable book or a scripted phonics lesson may be an appropriate and valuable resource for teaching a particular skill, but it cannot provide the full breadth of literacy development.

Programmes support particular aspects of instruction. They do not replace rich language experiences, knowledge-building across the curriculum or the professional expertise needed to bring all these elements together.

Structured Literacy is not something children simply complete when they reach the end of a programme. It is an approach to teaching and developing literacy that extends across the curriculum and throughout their education.


How Structured Literacy works alongside other frameworks and practices

Importantly, Structured Literacy can work within a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) and alongside Universal Design for Learning (UDL), trauma-informed and neuroaffirming practices, not against them.

These frameworks and approaches serve different but complementary purposes:

  • The Structured Literacy Framework provides the evidence-based principles for teaching the interconnected components of literacy, from foundational reading and spelling skills through to comprehension, writing and critical thinking.
  • MTSS Framework organises support across Tier 1 classroom instruction, Tier 2 targeted teaching and Tier 3 intensive specialist intervention. It recognises that some children, particularly those with dyslexia and persistent literacy difficulties, require more intensive and individualised teaching than mainstream classroom instruction alone can provide.
  • UDL Framework helps remove barriers to learning by providing different ways for children to access information, participate and demonstrate what they know, without replacing explicit instruction.
  • Trauma-informed practice recognises how experiences of trauma and stress can affect learning, attention, memory and emotional regulation. It emphasises safety, predictable routines, supportive relationships and avoiding practices that may cause further distress.
  • Neuroaffirming practice recognises and respects neurological differences, builds on children’s strengths and supports individual needs without expecting neurodivergent learners to think, communicate or behave exactly like their peers.

What does this look like in practice?

Example 1 – Different learning needs in the classroom

Take a classroom learning about the different ways to spell the /ā/ sound. One child may quickly understand and apply the spelling patterns, while another may need additional modelling, guided practice and cumulative review. A child with dyslexia may require more intensive instruction and specialist intervention to develop accurate, automatic word recognition.

The knowledge being taught remains consistent, but the amount of teaching, practice and support changes according to the learner.

This is why assessment matters. Teachers need to know what children have learned, what they have retained and where difficulties remain to make informed decisions about what to teach next.

Example 2 – How the frameworks work together

A child with dyslexia may receive explicit decoding instruction through Structured Literacy, use text-to-speech to access age-appropriate content through UDL, and receive specialist literacy intervention through MTSS.

These approaches are not competing with one another. Each addresses a different need. The child continues developing their reading skills while also accessing curriculum content appropriate to their age and understanding.

Example 3 – Trauma-informed and neuroaffirming teaching

A child with dyslexia may have struggled to read for years, with repeated failure, frustration or anxiety about literacy lessons. They may also have ADHD, autism or other learning differences that affect their attention, working memory, communication or ability to regulate their emotions.

A trauma-informed and neuroaffirming approach recognises these experiences and individual differences without lowering expectations or removing essential literacy instruction.

For example, a child who becomes anxious when asked to read aloud in front of classmates can still receive explicit reading instruction, but in a more supportive setting. The teacher might provide opportunities to practise privately, allow additional processing time, use predictable routines and build on the child’s strengths.

The literacy knowledge being taught remains the same, but how the child is supported to access and participate in that learning is adapted to their needs.


So, is Structured Literacy one-size-fits-all?

No. A one-size-fits-all approach treats all learners the same. Structured Literacy does the opposite.

It provides an evidence-based framework for teaching literacy while allowing instruction to be targeted, responsive and individualised.

It does not replace MTSS, UDL, trauma-informed or neuroaffirming practices. Nor does it remove the need for specialist literacy teachers, appropriate adjustments or intensive intervention.

These approaches can work together, each addressing a different aspect of effective and inclusive education.

Structured Literacy is the evidence-based framework and approach. Programmes are tools for putting it into practice. Teachers’ knowledge, creativity, professional judgement and ability to respond to the children in front of them remain essential.


Written by Sharon Scurr Founder of Dyslexia Evidence Based 17 October 2026